the ring...

there is a city..which is full of thieves....john wants to send a ring to mary...but since the city is full of thieves..so he put the ring in a box...and put a lock on it...if he sends this to mary...mary cannot open it since she is not having the keys...and also..sending another box containing the key..with another lock over it..would not solve the problem....so...can u help john to send this ring to mary...????

(they are not thieves.....)

10 Answers

41
Rwitwik Sinha ·

John can send the ring in a locked box the key to which only John has. On getting the box Mary can put another lock on it the key to which only she will have, then send it back to John. Then John will unlock his lock and resend it to Mary with Mary's lock still on. On getting the box Mary will be able to unlock it as she has the key.

119
Vinayak Agrawal ·

If it is a modern city, John attaches a machine to the box which would scan the holder's retina. If the scan result matches Mary's retina, it would open otherwise it wont.
And if the city is old-fashioned, he need not give her a ring, he might just propose her with flowers.

  • Vinayak Agrawal And if you ask how the machine would get Mary's retina pattern initially, John calls her and asks her to come home and takes her retina scan. Note: I could have used fingerprints too but in a modern city, the thieves would be able to forge the fingerprint of anyone who has touched the box (which Mary would have certainly done at John's home.
  • Vinayak Agrawal And if you ask how the machine would get Mary's retina pattern initially, John calls her and asks her to come home and takes her retina scan. Note: I could have used fingerprints too but in a modern city, the thieves would be able to forge the fingerprint of anyone who has touched the box (which Mary would have certainly done at John's home.
  • Vinayak Agrawal Sorry for the the repetition of the same comment twice. Laptop hanged
269
Astha Gupta ·

WOW....u r watching CID quite frequently these days...huh..???...impressive idea...but..u just think that if john called mary to his house ..... then why didn't he simply gave her the ring at that time only...he could have saved a lot of money..by not installing the system.......
still..again i appreciate...ur thinking...cool idea..but...u r thinking beyond john's BUDGET...

51
jinia pal ·

it's better that you solve it yourself..!!!!!

269
Astha Gupta ·

well...i have the key to this question...but still wanted everyone to workout with their brains to help out john... :p

51
jinia pal ·

then john would have to tell mary to break the box which contains the key....!!!!!!!:D

119
Vinayak Agrawal ·

It is so simple!!!!!!1111

John,the idiot, goes to Mary's home and gives her the ring.

269
Astha Gupta ·

Mary would have loved that.....if John went to her house...but as I said that that the city is full of thieves so probably the thieves may loot him on the way....then...what will he do...???...so...better option was a strong box with a strong lock...I mean really strong...hard to break....
Your thinking was gud and simple......
But....try to solve it in the 'box and lock' way.....

269
Astha Gupta ·

yeah..well thats the ri8 answer...

41
Rwitwik Sinha ·

Thanks! :)

Your Answer

Close [X]