1
ABHI
·2010-04-26 22:54:35
i did it using refractive index....dnt knw hw akshay bhaiya did it
1
aposlil
·2010-04-27 06:19:39
Akshay's correct. Answer is D). Doppler effect is applicable in this case.
39
Pritish Chakraborty
·2010-04-27 06:06:47
Yaar even I think Akshay is right...a star moving away provides a red shift. Doppler's effect in light has to be applied somehow..
Define "special" abhirup. lol..
Q1. All I know is that there is a relation
cot²∂1 + cot²∂2 = cot²∂
Now how you're going to get the answer from that, I have no idea...
1
ABHI
·2010-04-26 23:05:28
so d shud b answer, now v hv 2 think of a valid reason
my reason is using refractive index, refractive index decreasin so wavelngth must increase.
n akshay bhaiya sayin abt doppler effect, as it is goin away, its frequency decreases so wavelenth must increase..but as far as i read, doppler effect is not valid for spacial things...
tabh valid reason kya hoga?
1
Akshay Pamnani
·2010-04-26 23:00:16
@ Abhirup
maybe u r correct,but then wat is the use of the fact that star is going away??
1
ABHI
·2010-04-26 22:57:46
i jst want 2 confirm my way of thinking frm akshay bhaiya first....n akshay bhaiya, doppler effect is not applicable for cosmic particles...so how r u puttin it 4 the star thing?
1
Akshay Pamnani
·2010-04-26 22:57:17
@ Abhirup
ya but then wat is the use of the fact that the star is going away
I am sure Doppler's effect has to be used here
1
ABHI
·2010-04-26 22:55:38
cant v thing of using refractive index...n laboratory is certainly denser than the outer space....
so refractive index is lower in the outer space...so the wavelength must increase
1
Avinav Prakash
·2010-04-26 21:37:15
velo of air from A to B=v+w
so t1=xv+w
velo of air from B to A=v-w
t2=xv-w
use this reln to gwt b) as ans
1
Akshay Pamnani
·2010-04-26 22:54:14
Doppler's effect
appearent frequency would decrease and wavelength increase
But is the Doppler's effect applicable to Hydrogen Spectrum??
1
Manmay kumar Mohanty
·2010-04-26 22:52:06
can u explain how...............
I culdn't thnk of anythng when i saw this problem [2]
1
Akshay Pamnani
·2010-04-26 22:39:23
@ Manmay
mujhe dikh nahi raha Q3
1
Manmay kumar Mohanty
·2010-04-26 21:46:20
Q3)
The four line Balmer series spectrum shown below is emitted by a hydrogen sample in a laboratory. A star moving away frm Earth also emits a hydrogen spectrum.

WHICH spectrum might be observed on Earth for this star ?

IN abv options wavelngth ( x 10 -7 m)