IONIC 2

Which is Bronsted-Lowry acid as well as Arrhenius acid ?

H2 , HCO3- , NH3 or NH2- ?

Ans : HCO3-

6 Answers

29
govind ·

among the abv species only HCO3- can donate H+...

1
Bicchuram Aveek ·

why cannot it be like this : NH3 → H+ + NH2 - ????

then it also donates a proton ??? why can't it be ??

1
Tapas Gandhi ·

above stat + and accept too. (acid-base action in pairs)
satisfies condn for Bronsted-Lowry Theory

1
Manmay kumar Mohanty ·

according to arrhenius acid is a substance which furnishes H+ in aq. soln, while bronsted lowry stated that acid is a substance which has tendency to donate proton to another substance.

Now HCO3- satisfies these two while none other do

NH3 accepts proton but not donate them easily, H2 surely can't do any, NH2- can accept proton but doesn't furnish them

11
Devil ·

Aveek, already Nitrogen has a l.p, so ammonia cannot donate a proton, as Nitrogen becomes highly unstable with a l.p as werll as the electron of a hydrogen atom.

106
Asish Mahapatra ·

NH3 donates protons. (although quite rare). (as written by aveek)

think of sodamide..

NH3 is (more appropriately a base (not Bronsted base though)).. So It wont be included if single option ..

But multi option.. it is possible

Your Answer

Close [X]