Nature of roots

The equation A2/(x-a) + B2/(x-b) + C2/(x-c) + ..... + H2/(x-h) = k has

1) No real root
2) At most one real root
3) No complex root
4) At most two complex roots

8 Answers

1
aditya ravichandran ·

Ans i think is
3) no complex roots
edit

1
swordfish ·

yes how did you get that?

21
Shubhodip ·

DanTe^ ,sorry i made stupid mistake.

I am proving this for the equation A2/(x-a) + B2/(x-b) + C2/(x-c)+ D2/(x-d) = k (same arguments hold a,b,c,d,e,f,g,h )

Design a polynomial function f(x) = A2(x-a) B2(x-b)C2(x-c)D2(x-d)

Taking log and differentiating we can say f'(x)/f(x) = A2/(x-a) + B2/(x-b) + C2/(x-c)+ D2/(x-d)

So we have to solve f'(x)f(x) = k , or kf(x) - f'(x) = 0

Let P(x) = kf(x) - f'(x) ,Let k>0 (similar arguments hold for k<0)

From the graph of f(x)[drawn with help of Rolle's theorem] check the sign of p(x). from the figure given.

There is at least one root in between points of each sign change. Hence we clearly see 3 real roots of p(x). As p(x) is an polynomial equation with real co-efficients complex roots must occur in conjugate pairs. so there can't be a single complex root. so all roots are real.

(while checking the sign of p(x) , use the fact that when slope of tangent at any point is negative f'(x) at that point is negative)

341
Hari Shankar ·

I take it that A,B, ...,H, a,b,c...,k are all real

So, suppose z is a root, so is its conjugate

Hence

\frac{A^2}{z-a} + \frac{B^2}{z-b} +....+\frac{H^2}{z-h} =k

and

\frac{A^2}{\overline{z}-a} + \frac{B^2}{\overline{z}-b} +....+\frac{H^2}{\overline{z}-h} =k

Let z-\overline{z} = iR, R \in \mathbb{R}

Then subtracting and simplifying, we obtain

iR \left(\frac{A^2}{|z-a|^2} + \frac{B^2}{|z-b|^2} +....+\frac{H^2}{|z-h|^2} \right)=0

Since the bracketed term is positive, we must have R=0.

In other words roots are purely real

1
aditya ravichandran ·

awesome proofs

62
Lokesh Verma ·

one more proof could be by cross multiplying...

We see that the polynomial we have is of n degree...

Moreover the original question has one root between xi and xi+1 this is simply done by using limits because the right limit at xi is +ve infinity and left limit at xi+1 is - infinity

Also by saying that the function is continuous in between the limits...

Hence the polynomial has atleast n-1 roots...
There cant be 1 single complex root..
Hence all roots are Real.

1
aditya ravichandran ·

got it nishant bhaiya has used the asymptotes ,this gives the same resullt as that of shubodip

1708
man111 singh ·

Thanks Shubhodip, hsbhatt Sir and Nishant Sir.

Your Answer

Close [X]