Easiest of All...

Can we find a non-const. Polynomial which is prime for all integers x?

The co-efficents of the Polynomial are all integers.

7 Answers

1
Ricky ·

Let ' s assume there exists a non - constant polynomial F ( x ) such that eventually it takes all the

values of prime numbers .

Suppose for a particular value of x , say x = 1 , F ( x ) = P , where P is a prime number .

So we get , F ( 1 ) ≡ 0 ( mod P )

But for all integers Y , F ( 1 + PY ) = 0 ( mod P )

Hence , F ( 1 + PY ) cannot be a prime number as it is divisible by P .

So the only option left , is that F ( 1 ) = F ( 1 + PY ) .

But that also is not permissible as F ( x ) is not a constant function by our assumption .

So we conclude that there exists no such non - constant polynomial which can generate all the

prime numbers .

To prove that , F ( 1 + PY ) = 0 ( mod P ) ----- >

One can assume F ( x ) = a0 x n + a1 x n - 1 + .............

So F ( 1 ) = a0 + a1 + a2 + .............. = P

And F ( 1 + PY ) = a0 ( 1 + YP ) n + a1 ( 1 + YP ) n - 1 + .........

= { a0 + a1 + ................ } + YP ( ...............) - - - - - - -> { by binomial expansion }
= P + YP ( ................... )

Clearly , F ( 1 + PY ) is divisble by P also .

11
Devil ·

Yes, that's correct.

Alternately, we have for integers x' and k, P(x')=k.

Now substitute (x'+k) in place of x' and see the fun.

341
Hari Shankar ·

That's for polynomials in a single variable. I remember reading about a polynomial in some 10 variables that generates primes. Lets see if I can locate that source

62
Lokesh Verma ·

prophet sir, is that really true!

I thought that there exists none! I would be really interested in reading this one..

One argument, that i could give is that when all the 10 variables take the same value, it reduces to a polynomial of one variable.. which cannot have all values as primes..

Hence a polynomial of more than one varaiable too cannot!

341
Hari Shankar ·

I located it at last! (whew!).

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Formula_for_primes

He gives an example with 26 variables where +ve values taken by the polynomial are all the primes.

Note that he quotes a theorem by a Russian mathematician named Matiyasevich which already proves that such a polynomial will exist. So, a 10 variable one is also possible (thank god for that, i was wondering whether i was talking through my hat when I said that). That theorem is a landmark one as it decided a long standing problem named Hilbert's 10th problem

11
Devil ·

WOW! Big stuff up here....[152]

341
Hari Shankar ·

Ya, quite some level of abstraction. I was simply following links and I read this Matiyasevich theorem and in that link this 10th degree polynomial was mentioned. My joy and relief knew no bounds :D

Your Answer

Close [X]