basic qn on structure.

i have dbt regarding structures.

13 Answers

1
Arshad ~Died~ ·

lone pair electrons always exist in pairs because they have opposite spins and hence cancel the effect of each other......
i hope i am right....

1
Sunil Kumar ·

Whats the more stable configuration according to you?
Also an electron always form a pair in an orbital if they there is another electron available.

3
msp ·

y it shud form a pair.if it exists in pairs kq2/r2 r is so small, so huge force.so i think there must be some other reason,wat is gong to be changed incase of its spin.

can u explain breifly.

1
Arshad ~Died~ ·

opposite spins....so opposite electric fields.....hence they cancel out....
net electric field=0.....

3
msp ·

well i am speaking abt electrostatic force.

3
msp ·

sory A and B are interchanged.

1
Arshad ~Died~ ·

in ur structure...there are 3 90° bonds between l.p and b.p.
which results in unstable structure....as far as i know.....

3
msp ·

yeah this is wat i thot,but we dont know the relative stability,i want more confirmations da.

1
Sunil Kumar ·

@msp. Dude. Your structure is unstable according to me coz your structure has each electron pair has to face more repulsion from 3 bond pairs which are at right angles to it. U have placed lone pairs away but 3 lp bp repulsion is more than that. It increases the energy of the system and hence makes it unstable.

3
msp ·

yeah dude,i want something abt relative stability.

3
msp ·

just like we will do in finding the structure which contributes in the resonance hybrid.

24
eureka123 ·

Just find the number of repulsions to arrive at the right structure

lone pair=LP
bond pair=BP

the order is LP-LP>LP-BP>BP-BP

1
aieeee ·

ya,eure is right.this is the right way of judging the relative stability of structures.

the order LP-LP>LP-BP>BP-BP is considered effective only when any of these pair is at 900 wid each other.repul;sion is considered negligible when angle is 1200 or 1800. also, neglect the BP-BP repulsion as its too weak compared to the other two.

in the first structure : there are four 900 repulsions between lonepair and bonded pair and no lonepair-lonepair repulsion.

in the 2nd structure there are six 900 repulsions b/w bonded pair and lone pair but no lonepair-lonepair repulsion.

thus, 1st structure is more stable then the 2nd one.

Your Answer

Close [X]