excellent question

All points of the plane are colored red, blue or green. Prove that we can find two points a distance 1 apart with the same color.

19 Answers

341
Hari Shankar ·

perhaps he had an equilateral triangle and pigeonhole principle in mind

24
eureka123 ·

where was i wrong????????

62
Lokesh Verma ·

awesome work ith power :)

1
ith_power ·

yeah you are right i edited above.

9
Celestine preetham ·

small mistake in post5 it shud be a circle of radius √3

39
Dr.House ·

thats terrific ith power

1
ith_power ·

Existence of the equilateral triangle of side=2 (the r-r-r triangle) is established.
Now to avoid the condition, The midpoints are blue.
Then contradiction occurs for coloring the shown point.

1
ith_power ·

Yeah. But this type of problems always admit a solution using geometrical figures which is easier to find.

62
Lokesh Verma ·

ith power, cant we prove because we have proved already that the equilateral triangle exists, so by scaling the plane suitably (coordinate axes) we can get a right angled triangle of some size

and as soon as we get a right angled triangle of some dimenstion by scaling the axes again we can get a right angled triangle of the dimension that you want?

39
Dr.House ·

ya. we can do that also.

but i tried to make things as simple as possible

39
Dr.House ·

well, this is a beauty. no takers?

1
ith_power ·

YEP.
A harder one:

Show that there exists a monochromatic triangle of side 1,√3,2 . [in bicoloring the plane].

39
Dr.House ·

thanks .

i th power i guess u had same method in mind ?

1
satan92 ·

yes b55 that is it.. good work

39
Dr.House ·

ith power --

pick a distance d
pick a point; say it's red
draw a circle of radius d about it
if there is a red point on it, we're done
otherwise, every point on the circle is blue
pick a point on the circle and draw a circle of radius d about it
the circles intersect at a point which must be both red and blue; contradiction

1
Rohan Ghosh ·

hmm this is a famous problem ..

1
ith_power ·

proceed by assuming the contary.
consider two fused equilateral triangle of side 1 giving a rhombus. let it be ABCD.
Now if A is red, B is green(or blue) and C is blue(or green). So D is red.
Consider circle of radius √3 around A.
All points on the circle are locus of D. So the circle is red. then there is a unit lenghted chord.

Follow up question:
If two colours are used, prove that we can get two oints of same colour any d distance apart.
[its pretty easy but the method is ingenious]

24
eureka123 ·

39
Dr.House ·

then post the solution. if u have forgotten no need to say that

Your Answer

Close [X]