Colours again!

Colours in complexes are decided by the constituents of the coordination sphere, right? So why do K4[Fe(CN)6] and Fe2[Fe(CN)6] differ in colour though coordination sphere is intact?

230 Answers

11
Sunil Kumar ·

Vishal turns blue bull is ferrous ferricyanide that means inner iron in the coordination sphere has oxidation state +3........

11
Sunil Kumar ·

sorry it is turn bull's blue......

1
greatvishal swami ·

ye wahi to hai andar wala Fe3+ hai

oops written at same time:)

11
Sunil Kumar ·

if the central iron atom is Fe3+ then, the compound should be Fe3[Fe(CN)6]... and not Fe2[Fe(CN)6]....

11
Anirudh Narayanan ·

Andar wala +3 kaise ho sakta hai, yaar? Andar ek aur bahar do, sare Fe +2 me hi hain. teek se dhek

11
Anirudh Narayanan ·

It's not Fe22+. It's (Fe2+) twice.

11
Sunil Kumar ·

Aragorn, actually it was to contradict the vishal's point.......
check my previous posts......

1
greatvishal swami ·

yes andar wala2+ hee hai

11
Anirudh Narayanan ·

Did u get the question, Sunil? Coz i've not understood most of ur replies [2]

11
Sunil Kumar ·

actually this compound Fe2[Fe(CN)6] doesn't exits it is Fe3[Fe(CN)6] which exists.........

11
Anirudh Narayanan ·

How?

1
greatvishal swami ·

okay sunil bt wat bout
Zn2[Fe(CN)6] &Cu2[Fe(CN)6]
they both exist

11
Sunil Kumar ·

I checked it on net try searching for it. u'll not get any information on it...
Try it....

11
Sunil Kumar ·

@vishal, do they both have different colours......

1
greatvishal swami ·

@ ani its Fe3[Fe(CN)6]2
which exist & is called turn bull's blue

1
greatvishal swami ·

1st has bluish white colour

2nd has chocolate brown colour

11
Sunil Kumar ·

so what i said was correct??
the colour of the complex depends on splitting of d-orbital which depends on the oxidation state of central metal ion........

1
greatvishal swami ·

bt my cmpnds hav diff colours

and iron is in +2

11
Anirudh Narayanan ·

Well, finally u've come to my doubt.

1
greatvishal swami ·

i ws always wth u ani

11
Anirudh Narayanan ·

Sorry Vishal. That was @Sunil [1]

1
greatvishal swami ·

i know dat dude

11
Anirudh Narayanan ·

Thanx.

Sunil? where r u?

1
greatvishal swami ·

well g2g gys cheak the Q tommorow

gdnt

11
Sunil Kumar ·

dudes just let me think now..........
U came up wid the same problem and this thread is now restarted.....

11
Anirudh Narayanan ·

Gdnt, vishal!

Well, Sunil. Q has been the same since I posted it. Everyone's just got confused with the wordings and the other replies! [1]

11
Anirudh Narayanan ·

PPL, PLEASE POST THE ANSWER B4 I LEAVE[2]. I DON'T WANT THIS THREAD TO BECOME AN EXTINCT AND UNANSWERED ONE. LOT OF REPLIES BUT NO ANSWERS. [2]

9
Celestine preetham ·

im not sure jus guessing that
though coordination sphere is same , the outer surrounding elements are diff so during charge transfer , they may have diff effects

ne way dont worry to much abt this q , its not toatall relevent to jee syllabus , so we may not be in position to ans

9
Celestine preetham ·

or it may turn out that in sol the ions dissociate and colour is due to these ionic interactions

1
Honey Arora ·

i think it cn be linked with ionisation isomerism smhw...........bt i m nt sure..........i cldn't see any other reason..........

Your Answer

Close [X]